Showing posts with label The Pulps. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Pulps. Show all posts

Friday, August 4, 2023

Lamentations of the Flame Princess and the Pulp Pedigree - Observations on Original Dungeons & Dragons 1974 game, Original Traveller, and Lamentations of the Flame Princess rpg

 Alright let's pick it up from here. One thing that I noticed about Lamentations of the Flame Princess and original Dungeons & Dragons is the fact that both games pull quite heavily from thier respective  Pulp pedigrees. And this isn't a bad thing at all. With original Dungeons & Dragons this is evident right from the get go. 


























Because Lamentations pulls so heavily from it's Mentzer Dungeons & Dragons legacy the proof of the game is within it's editing by James Raggi the IV. And it's world setting is laid out within it's adventures. John Q Public within thier December 2019 Amazon  review sums up nicely some of the advantages of LoFP;"What you get is a clear and focused restatement of the Basic D&D rules focused on what those rules do best: survival horror. But unlike the high fantasy safari of Dungeons & Dragons, LotFP Weird Fantasy concentrates on desperate treasure hunters hailing from a grimy replica of our own planet in the Renaissance/early modern period, where magic is a dreadful aberration and ne'er-do-wells who rob tombs and chance brushes with unknown horrors are shunned.

"The "D&D" you get is a finely-crafted rendition of the classic game: 7 classes include the Cleric, Fighter, Magic-User, Specialist, Dwarf, Elf, and Halfling. Saving Throws are divided into 5 categories, and magic involves spellbooks, memorization, casting, and forgetting. Attacks are resolved with a d20 roll compared with a range of Armor Classes, modified by Dexterity. XP is earned almost entirely by recovering treasure from dangerous adventure sites.
Each place where Weird Fantasy differs from Mentzer's Basic D&D really doubles down on the game's weird survival horror vision. Characters have 3 Alignments as in Basic—Neutral, Law, and Chaos—but it represents your character's role in a cosmic conflict regardless of their moral outlook. Certain classes are polarized by Alignment: Clerics must be Lawful, and Magic-Users and Elves must be Chaotic. Furthermore, the rules otherwise treat Elves as inhuman monsters, making them vulnerable to holy water and certain spells cast by Clerics." 

"Another big player-facing difference is that only Fighters get better attack bonuses as they increase in level. This helps really set them apart from the other classes. The Specialist, which is the Weird Fantasy alternative to the Thief class in D&D, has a unique skill system that gives players the option to create a wide variety of characters by specializing in different adventuring skills."

Original Dungeons & Dragons plugs into the same flexibility of system as LoFP but in a different direction. This is evident within OD&D 1974's wargaming roots and implimations of system. 
And here's where Traveller comes in once again. Traveller's 2d6 original 1977 system was also born out of it's era and wargaming roots to a certain extent. It's very nature allows it's flexibility and service ability as a game. 
The players of these games can literally with a few rolls come up with a workable campaign on the fly. And these campaigns plug into the literary source material and this is something we see in original Dungeons & Dragons as well as Traveller. Both games ply from thier sources one being Sword & Sorcery and the other being Space Opera respectively both being sources from different aspects of the Pulp magazine era. And LoFP also pulling from the Weird Fantasy era of the you guessed it the Pulps. 
Why!? Because there's something very compelling about the Pulp asthetic as a role player and gamer. And this is one of the reasons why we keep coming back to the table top because it's within these rpg systems mathematics and make up. 

Thursday, August 3, 2023

Possibilities & Glory - Observations on Original Dungeons & Dragons 1974 game, & Original Traveller Rpg

If there's a game that is loved around the table top then we begin looking deeper into it. And with Gencon on this weekend it's no wonder that once again Original Dungeons & Dragons '74 is on the table top. So let's pick it up right from here on the blog. 



And weirdly enough there was a lot of push back on this last blog entry because of the mention of Lamentations of the Flame Princess Rpg and it was mentioned because it's a B/X clone. Original Dungeons & Dragons 1974 has own distinctive flavor all it's own. And a bunch of fans & players which is right in line with observations made in the Original Dungeons & Dragons wiki entry going back to the early days of Space Gamer magazine;" Tim Waddell reviewed the original Dungeons & Dragons in The Space Gamer #2.[7] Waddell commented that "The most stimulating part of the game is the fact that anything can happen. Nothing is impossible."[7] Andy Pudewa also reviewed the original Dungeons & Dragons in The Space Gamer #2.[8] Pudewa said that "As a game, D&D is a fantastical outlet for the imagination. It has the quality of being infinitely flexible, and with it comes the reality of impossibility. [...] There are drawbacks to the game however; as there are in any game. D&D cannot even begin to get interesting in less than 20 hours playing time. Hundreds of hours of work must be done ahead of time by the referee, and it takes a fairly long time to prepare on the part of the players."

My point here is the wide openness of the original Dungeons & Dragons system in lue of the more restrictive rpg systems of fifth edition Dungeons & Dragons of today. And please don't give me the fact that it's the same game. These are very different animals deriaved from different branches of the Original Dungeons & Dragons tree. Original Dungeons & Dragons is in a word infinitely flexible gaming. Or is it just one little aspect of the 'grand game'. And I personally think that this goes back to the wargaming roots of original Dungeons & Dragons. 
And other original Seventies era games such as Marc Miller's original Traveller rpg. And these two games can and have worked closely together in the past at the table top. An interesting insight was had by one of my players while searchingt through the Original Dungeons & Dragons forums on Traveller from 2010 member Slade wrote; "For what it's worth I believe En Garde! is to Traveller what Braunstein is to OD&D.


En Garde!
 is the char gen framework that inspired the char gen mini-game in Traveller." 
This style of mini game gives the characters background, skills, and gravitas that we see in both the Pulp stories of the 1930's through 1970's. A call back to the skilled and above average heroes of old. And this is something that both original Dungeons & Dragons and Original Traveller have in common. 


































The possibilities that you can and will be able to do anything campaign wise with these two games is pretty mind blowing. And continue to play them since 1970's until now is pretty mind blowing. It's almost like that ulitity is design into these products. Endless possiblities in a hand full of dice! But how do they work together?! Next time we dive head first into these systems together! 

Tuesday, August 1, 2023

Lean & Mean - Observations on Original Dungeons & Dragons 1974 game, Original Traveller, and Lamentations of the Flame Princess rpg

 When it comes to original Dungeons & Dragons there's a bit of a sense of romance about the grand game. And while some players have dismissed the OD&D game. For myself it remains a timeless classic and this is because for me as a player there's something that sparks interest from the ground up.
Being on the otherside of the screen for me as a player has been a bit well, different.  
















And one of those things that hits different is the fact of not how limited in scope Original Dungeons & Dragons is but how without all of the 'gaming dogma' the game handles itself like a well playing machine if you know what your doing with it as a DM. 
And the 'Reviews from Rlyeh blog hits this pattern on the head in thier Original Dungeons & Dragons 1974 review;  " Nicely though, the Foreword to ‘Volume 1: Men & Magic’ prefigures the famous ‘Appendix N’ in the Dungeon Master’s Guide for Advanced Dungeons & Dragons. It suggests Edgar Rice Burroughs’ Martian stories, Robert E. Howard’s Conan tales, Fritz Leiber’s Fafhrd and the Gray Mouser adventures as inspiration. These suggestions point to a more pulpy inspiration, but what is curious is an absence from the list—J.R.R. Tolkien. So no The Hobbit and no The Lord of the Rings. Their later inclusion as inspiration would arguably make Dungeons & Dragons a much drier game, but their influence is very, very much in evidence here in terms of the Classes and Races available to play, and then equally, if not more so, in later editions of Dungeons & Dragons"

 1974 Original Dungeons & Dragons feels far more wide open to me as both player and DM in a way. This is something that we see in original Traveller as well. The inclusion of too many gaming details and elements seems to take away from the actual play. And the reason for this maybe that too much gaming crunch and lore can actually hinder play. 
And yet there's something more of the wargame here as well as the blueprints for the grand game. Because at it's core that's what original Dungeons & Dragons is, the blue print and the grand game itself. 
The fact that original dungeons & dragons has such a 'nuts & bolts' approach to it's material means that literally other material can be used and you won't break original Dungeons & Dragons. 

And this in point of fact goes back to both Appendix N and original Traveller's Pulp roots. In Tales to Astound a wordpress blog this exact observation has been made back in 2015; "For years I was one of those people who had a “dissatisfaction with picaresque stories.” And for this reason, as Maliszewski properly guesses, I saw “D&D as lacking in some way.”

Unexpectedly, as I dig into (and enjoy immensely) the Lamentations of the Flame Princess game I’m running for my friends, I’m really coming to enjoy the pulp tales. I’m no longer dissatisfied with them, and really loving the rules for doing what they’re doing." What's interesting to me as both player & DM is the how and why everything always comes back down to the Pulps source material made these games great. And another reason why I think Lamentations of the Flame Princess needs more credit then it gets within the OSR.